Hot Pepper Jelly Grilled Cheese

Ready to melt into a world of ooey-gooey perfection? The hot pepper jelly grilled cheese is a sweet and spicy delight! Get ready to elevate soup season with a grilled cheese that’s anything but average.

Why I Love This Recipe

When you’re craving comfort food on a chilly day, a grilled cheese always hits the spot. But if you’re ready to take your sandwich game to a whole new level of ooey-gooey, sweet-and-spicy delight, then you have to try my hot pepper jelly grilled cheese!

Hot pepper jelly has always been nostalgic for me. And combining that zing with the freshness of thinly-sliced apples and the sharpness of the cheddar is like taking everything I love about fall and layering it between two slices of sourdough. So good!

We all know soup season starts as soon as those temperatures drop. But what’s a delicious, cozy soup without a really great sandwich on the side, you know? And I seriously can’t think of a better option than pairing your bowl of comfort with a fall grilled cheese with apple, cheddar, and jam.

If you’ve been dreading the colder weather, a sweet and spicy grilled cheese will warm you right up. Pair it with your favorite soup or salad, and I guarantee you’ll be eating this combo on repeat all season long!

What’s in a Hot Pepper Jelly Grilled Cheese?

The perfect sandwich is all about balance and simplicity. Let’s take a look at how to make a sweet and spicy grilled cheese sandwich with just 5 ingredients.

First, we start with sourdough bread for that sturdy, tangy base. We’ll melt butter in the skillet and lay each slice in the butter to help achieve that irresistible golden crunch.

Next, slather the insides of each slice with hot pepper jelly for that sweet and spicy burst of flavor. Then you’ll add the sharp cheddar slices to both sides of the sandwich to make sure we have PLENTY of cheese.

Finally, arrange the apple slices on one side, then cook to golden perfection! Once you take a bite, you’ll see how adding just a few key ingredients really takes the traditional grilled cheese to that next level.

Variations for Sweet and Spicy Grilled Cheese

When a sandwich is this good, it’s hard to go wrong. If you feel like playing around with the flavors, don’t hesitate to get creative!

Want to crank up the cozy factor? Throw in some caramelized onions for a touch of earthy sweetness.

Or maybe you want to add some savory goodness? You can never go wrong with bacon! And with the extra protein, this is a great way to turn your sandwich into a full, satisfying meal.

Want to play around with the cheese? I love sharp cheddar because it stands up to the strong flavor of the hot pepper jelly, but you could always swap out another kind of cheese if you like. What could be more fun than experimenting with different cheeses?

What to Serve with Fall Grilled Cheese

• Carnitas Tortilla Soup — The browned pork adds rich flavor to this classic cozy soup!
• Chicken & Sweet Potato Chili —  If you have some leftover pulled chicken, do yourself a favor and make this super easy chili.
• Dairy Free Cauliflower Chowder —  Cauliflower and almond milk are the perfect combo to make this creamy soup without any dairy!
• Pasta Fagioli Soup —  Would you believe the secret to this tasty soup is that half-used jar of marinara hiding in the back of your fridge?

How to Store Hot Pepper Jelly Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

Let’s be real: any grilled cheese is best served hot and fresh right off the skillet. But if you have leftovers, you can always store them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week. I recommend reheating in a pan on the stove until the cheese is melted. 

Prepping for a crowd? Assemble the sandwiches, then wrap them up and store them in the fridge. When you’re ready to eat, simply melt the butter in the skillet and cook to golden perfection!

Other Delicious Sandwich Recipes

Caprese Chicken Sandwich

Copycat Panera Chicken Frontega Panini

Maple Dijon Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Roasted Butternut Squash & Apple Grilled Cheese

Print